At KACM, indifference is not an option; emotions run high. Fans love, hope, worry, criticize, but most importantly, they continue to believe. The Kawkab is not merely a football club; it is intertwined with the memory and identity of Marrakech, reflecting both its glorious moments and its challenging times.
This deep attachment necessitates a moment of reflection to evaluate the club's current state with objectivity. This is not a trial or a defense; rather, it is an acknowledgment of achievements, recognition of areas needing improvement, and preparation for the future.
When Idriss Hanifa took over the reins of the club, Kawkab was emerging from several particularly difficult years marked by financial troubles, administrative issues, sporting instability, and injuries that had significantly impacted the institution. In this context, revitalizing the club was undoubtedly a monumental task.
The management style of the president has certainly elicited mixed reactions. While some appreciate his firmness and decisiveness, others criticize him for a governance approach that leans too much towards the personal and allows insufficient room for dissenting opinions. However, one can question a method without dismissing the results achieved.
The most visible achievement is the return of Kawkab to the elite ranks of Moroccan football. After several seasons in lower divisions, regaining a spot in Botola Pro 1 is a significant milestone. For supporters who have faced years of disappointment, this resurgence represents far more than just a sporting achievement; it symbolizes the restoration of pride.
Progress has also been made in other areas, such as addressing some financial constraints, restructuring, and logistical improvements, including resources aimed at aligning the club with professional standards. However, financial liabilities amounting to nearly four billion centimes serve as a reminder of the considerable debt the club must contend with. The personal commitment of the president to the club’s operations also deserves recognition.
Nevertheless, not all issues have been resolved. Youth development remains a top priority, especially given Kawkab's long-standing tradition of scouting and nurturing talent. Enhancing communication and governance is also essential for greater efficiency and openness.
The successive departures of Tarik Smires and Youssef Dahir from the management board raise questions in this regard. Without attributing intentions to anyone, these changes prompt a discussion about the role of debate, collegiality, and dissent in the club's leadership.
Leadership encompasses not only decision-making but also listening, persuading, and unifying. The upcoming general assembly should provide an opportunity to discuss these issues calmly. The focus should not be on settling scores but on learning from the past to build a brighter future.
Idriss Hanifa is, of course, not beyond criticism. However, to reduce his tenure at the helm of Kawkab solely to his management style would be equally simplistic. There have been achievements and efforts, but also mistakes and legitimate inquiries.
Thus, the real question is not whether one is for or against a single individual; it is about what kind of Kawkab Marrakech we envision for the future: a stronger, more professional, more transparent, and ultimately more unifying club.
The Kawkab is larger than its presidents and more significant than any rivalries that may exist. Therefore, let us give credit where credit is due—nothing more, nothing less.
As reported by lopinion.ma.
